Welcome to AJ’s Pizza

Where Every Slice Tells a Story!

Decades of Good Vibes and Great Pizzas

All About That Top-Notch Quality

Free Delivery, Dine-in & Take-out serving: Bloomingdale, Butler, Haskell, Kinnelon, Pompton Lakes, Riverdale Sections of West Milford

AJ’s Pizzeria has always been known for quality ingredients. Our dough is rolled fresh each day, add our zesty red sauce and juicy premium meats and fresh gourmet veggies on top of our world famous crust and you have the best pizza in all the land!

Our Menu

Fresh from the oven waiting for you
Homemade sauce and secret spices
Delicious hot and cold subs
Take-Out • Delivery • Dine In
12 Main St. • Butler

973 - 283 - 0454

Take-Out • Free Delivery
Mon.-Thurs. 11am-9pm Fri. & Sat. 11am-10pm Sun. 11:30am-9pm
Delivery to Butler, Bloomingdale, Riverdale, Pompton Lakes, Kinnelon, Haskell, Pomption Plants and West Mildford
Catering Available For All Occasions

Our Services

Free Delivery

We offer free delivery on all orders over $6.00.

Read more

Gift Cards

Give the gift of AJ’s Pizza this holiday season! Buy AJ’s Gift Cards online!

Read more

AJ’s Pizza Rewards

Sign up now to earn points on every order and start enjoying member-only benefits.

Read more

Catering Services

Looking for catering? Look no further than AJ’s. We provide catering for any occasion..

Read more